No Wrong Turtles

He was born on one turtle, I on another; what is the love and happiness of two men compared to this simple truth?

The night is dark, the stars hidden behind the haze, the Dual City’s lanterns dimmed for the seventh and last day of Leave Taking. I don’t need light, I can see him with my eyes closed, with my back turned, with my hope gone. 

We sway in the wind because the bridges between the two enormous shells are made of rope, not stone or wood, because this day was always coming, because the turtle that carries his city on its back will turn one way and the one that bears mine the other, swimming their separate paths across the surface of the World Ocean, tearing my heart.

I was ten when the two great reptiles came together, when our city suddenly doubled in size and we met our new neighbors. Strange smells filled the air, the spices and cured meats of his side clashing with the yeasts and roasted nuts of mine. Strange sounds surrounded us, the hard consonants of my mother’s tongue making space for the airy vowels that rode in on the other beast’s back. The bright blue of his people’s roofs and the muted browns and greens of the streets where I took my first steps.

He was kicking a ball made of cloth scraps salvaged from the floor of his family’s workshop. I was chasing a small, self-propelled, flying toy my favorite uncle had folded and wound.

The ball hit my flying machine and brought it down like one of my sisters’ cats catching a firefly.

“Oh no! I am so sorry!” he said in that lovely musical speech that I thought at first was from his turtle but now know is just him, how he speaks to the world.

I stared. 

I’d never met anybody like him. Not just his hair color, not just the shape of his eyes, his odd clothes. The way he stood, the quiet smile, the absolute assurance of who he was, of where he was, why, and how. He was open and generous—he reached out instead of closing in. 

I fell in love on the spot, though I wouldn’t realize this until much later, when my spirit grew into my body.

He extended his hand. I took it and we ran off together, best friends at first, then tentative explorations, first love, side by side always, but now heartbreak because he was born on the wrong turtle, or I was.

There’s no question of changing sides. We tried that already. 

I made a vow to spend a fortnight in his house, not stepping foot on my own side the whole time. 

I felt a yearning, a wrongness, after a few hours. But everybody’s felt that, they always go back to their side at night, so no harm comes.

If you stay on the wrong turtle, as I did, you start to get dizzy, then sick, then really sick, then it’s fever, vomit, and death—they say—but I didn’t make it that far. A day and a half, and barely that.

He’s stronger than me. He lasted two whole days and nights on my side. He was so pale I could almost see through him. I pushed and cajoled and carried him back to his own half-city.

So tonight we sit on the thinnest bridge, just a few ropes with a handrail on each side, letting the sea wind move us like two leaves, and staring between the turtles at the dark water that will soon become an entire ocean. 

The silence is almost comforting, as if we could hold back tomorrow by not speaking of it.

I fall asleep leaning on the shoulder of my one love, my legs tangled in the bridge’s thick threads, his fingers in my hair.

Seabirds cry awake the dreaded day, with sun too bright and wind too calm.

There’s a hush, as the two halves of our world wait to be torn apart. 

People line the facing edges of each turtle’s shell.

I should go back to my side and he to his, but we linger, daring the structure to snap underneath us as the great beasts swim their separate ways. 

Unseen flippers upset the stillness of the water’s surface. 

Ropes tense, the bridge loses its downward curve, a note ascends as if someone were tuning a gigantic lute. 

I hold his hand as he holds mine, not so much a decision as not being willing to make one.

The sea between the turtles boils and bubbles and foams. 

One rope surrenders with a loud twang. The bridge twists to its side. We hold on to the remaining threads. 

People are yelling—excited, scared, surprised—but we have no time for them, for anything but each other.

A moment, suspended, stretched out. 

A spray of seawater. 

A rush of wind. 

A fall.

A rough landing on a surface hard and slick with water sluicing off. 

The plants are seaweed. The smell is of the ocean’s depths.

People cheer. 

He laughs—he’s always been quicker than me.

“Look,” he says, and sweeps his arm around. 

I turn. We’re on the back of a turtle. Smaller, shinier, with no streets, no buildings, no factories or fields or forests on its back, but a turtle, nonetheless.

I laugh too, for the first time in months. I feel right the same way I felt wrong during my attempt at living on his side.

We were always told that nobody knew why the two great reptiles had come together, but it’s obvious in hindsight; we stand on their child, the turtle where we will build a new city, a new home, a new life. 

Other people join us: singletons, lovers in twos and threes and more, seekers and artists from both sides in every shape and color and music. Because today, on this perfect, warm morning, there are no wrong turtles.

© 2026 Rodrigo Culagovski

Rodrigo is a Chilean author, architect, and web developer. He has published stories in markets such as Escape Pod, Flash Fiction Online, Nature, Levar Burton Reads, and khōréō among others. Currently querying his first novel, about a hypothetical advanced civilization in the pre-Columbian Amazon. Online and on Bluesky as @culagovski.net.

Previous
Previous

Ticket to a New Body

Next
Next

Splinters